Non-defining relative clauses
extra information between commas: My sister, who lives in Ohio, is a nurse
A non-defining relative clause adds extra information about a noun that is already clear, and it goes between commas: My sister, who lives in Ohio, is a nurse. It uses who, which, whose, where or when, never that, and the pronoun cannot be left out. Which can also refer to a whole idea: He was late, which annoyed me.
Tables
Defining and non-defining
| Feature | Defining | Non-defining |
|---|---|---|
| Job | says which one | adds extra information |
| Commas | no commas | commas around the clause |
| that | possible | not possible |
| Leaving out the pronoun | possible when it is the object | never |
| Example | The car that I bought is red. | My car, which I bought last year, is red. |
Pronouns in non-defining clauses
| Pronoun | Use | Example |
|---|---|---|
| who | people, subject or object | My boss, who is from Texas, is very friendly. |
| whom | people, object, formal | The director, whom I met once, was charming. |
| which | things, or a whole clause | The museum, which opened in 1990, is free. |
| whose | possession | Ana, whose son is in my class, is a doctor. |
| where | places | We went to Lisbon, where my aunt lives. |
| when | times | I'll call you on Friday, when I'm back. |
| some of which, most of whom | a part of a group | I have three cousins, all of whom live abroad. |
Defining or non-defining
A defining clause tells you which person or thing. A non-defining clause gives extra information about a person or thing you already know. If you remove a non-defining clause, the sentence still makes full sense.
Names, unique things and nouns with my, this and similar words are often already clear, so the clause after them is usually non-defining: Paris, which is the capital of France, is huge.
Examples
-
My father, who is 70, still goes running.
-
The Nile, which flows through Egypt, is very long.
-
Our new teacher, who comes from Ireland, is great.
-
The students who passed got a certificate.
Defining: only the students who passed.
Commas change the meaning
Commas show that the clause is extra. Compare My brother who lives in Rome is a chef, which suggests I have more than one brother, with My brother, who lives in Rome, is a chef, which suggests I have one brother.
In speech the commas are pauses. When the clause ends the sentence, there is only one comma, before it.
Examples
-
The workers, who were tired, went home.
All the workers were tired.
-
The workers who were tired went home.
Only the tired ones went home.
-
I met Sam, who works with my wife.
No that, and no leaving out
In non-defining clauses do not use that: My phone, which is new, has a great camera, not My phone, that is new. Use who for people and which for things.
The pronoun cannot be left out, even when it is the object: This book, which I read last week, was great.
Examples
-
Her car, which she bought in May, has already broken down.
-
Mr. Lee, who you met yesterday, is our new manager.
-
The hotel, which my friend recommended, was perfect.
Which for a whole clause
Which can refer to the whole idea of the previous clause, not only to one noun. It always follows a comma. What cannot be used this way: He passed, which surprised everyone, not what surprised everyone.
Examples
-
She didn't call, which was strange.
-
The train was late, which meant we missed the show.
-
He offered to pay, which was very kind of him.
Whom and preposition + which
In formal English whom is used when the person is the object: the writer, whom I admire. In everyday English who is normal here.
In formal style a preposition can come before which or whom: the house, in which he was born, my teacher, to whom I owe a lot. In informal style the preposition goes at the end: my teacher, who I owe a lot to.
Examples
-
The singer, whom fans had waited for, finally arrived.
-
The old bridge, across which we drove, was built in 1890.
-
My grandmother, to whom I wrote every week, lived in Maine.
Some of which, all of whom
A quantifier + of which or of whom talks about part of a group or the whole group: some of which, many of whom, none of which, both of whom, most of which. Use which for things and whom for people. Who is not possible after of here.
Examples
-
She has four sisters, two of whom are twins.
-
I bought ten apples, most of which were bad.
-
He wrote five books, none of which sold well.
Common mistakes
-
Wrong My mother, that is a doctor, works at night.
Right My mother, who is a doctor, works at night.
That is not used in non-defining clauses. Use who for people and which for things.
-
Wrong Our house, we bought in 2015, is near the sea.
Right Our house, which we bought in 2015, is near the sea.
In a non-defining clause the pronoun cannot be left out, even when it is the object.
-
Wrong He failed the test, what upset his parents.
Right He failed the test, which upset his parents.
To refer to a whole clause, use which. What means the thing that and does not work here.
-
Wrong I have two brothers, both of who are engineers.
Right I have two brothers, both of whom are engineers.
After a preposition like of, the form for people is whom.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between defining and non-defining relative clauses?
A defining clause identifies which person or thing: The man who called is here. A non-defining clause adds extra facts about someone already identified, and it has commas: Mr. Brown, who called earlier, is here. Non-defining clauses never use that and never drop the pronoun.
Can I use that in a non-defining clause?
No. After a comma use who for people and which for things: My laptop, which is three years old, still works. That is possible only in defining clauses, with no commas: The laptop that I use for work is old.
Is whom still used in English?
Yes, but mostly in formal writing and after prepositions: to whom, with whom, some of whom. In conversation people usually say who for an object: my cousin, who I visited last week. After a preposition, whom is the only correct form.
More in this section
Read English at this level
Grammar sticks when you meet it in real sentences. These pages have English texts with a translation under every sentence.