Relative clauses: who, which, that
who for people, which for things, that for both: the man who called
A defining relative clause tells you which person or thing you mean: the man who called, the book that I bought. Use who for people, which for things, that for both, whose for possession, where for places and when for times. When the pronoun is the object, you can leave it out: the book I bought.
Tables
Relative pronouns
| Pronoun | Refers to | Example |
|---|---|---|
| who | people | The woman who lives next door is a nurse. |
| which | things, animals | The bus which goes to the airport is late. |
| that | people or things | The phone that I bought is broken. |
| whose | possession, people or things | That's the boy whose dog bit me. |
| where | places | This is the café where we met. |
| when | times | I remember the day when you were born. |
| why | after the reason | That's the reason why I called. |
| whom | people as object, formal | The man whom she married is French. |
Subject or object: can you leave it out?
| Role of the pronoun | Example | Leave it out? |
|---|---|---|
| subject | the girl who won the race | no |
| subject | the train that leaves at six | no |
| object | the girl (who) I met | yes |
| object | the film (that) we watched | yes |
| object of a preposition | the town (that) I grew up in | yes |
What a defining relative clause does
A defining relative clause comes right after a noun and tells you which one you mean. Without it, the sentence is unclear: The man is my uncle does not say which man. With it, the meaning is complete: The man who is talking to Ana is my uncle.
There are no commas around a defining clause.
Examples
-
The people who live upstairs are very loud.
-
I lost the ring that my grandma gave me.
-
Do you know anyone who speaks Italian?
-
The keys which were on the table are gone.
Who, which and that
Use who for people and which for things and animals. That works for both and is very common in speech, especially for things. In American English that is preferred for things in defining clauses.
After all, everything, something, nothing, anything and after superlatives, use that (or no pronoun) rather than which:the best movie that I've seen.
Examples
-
She's the teacher who helped me most.
-
This is the dress that I want.
-
Is there anything that I can do?
-
It's a machine which makes coffee and tea.
Whose for possession
Whose replaces his, her, its or their and joins a noun to the thing it has: the man whose car was stolen. It is followed by a noun and is used for people, and also for things and places.
Examples
-
I have a friend whose father is a pilot.
-
That's the family whose house burned down.
-
We stayed in a town whose name I forget.
Where and when
Where follows a noun of place and means in which or at which. When follows a noun of time and means on which or in which. You can often leave out when: the day we met.
If the clause needs an object, use that or which, not where: the city that we visited, but the city where we lived.
Examples
-
This is the hospital where I was born.
-
Do you know a shop where I can buy stamps?
-
Summer is the time when most people travel.
Leaving out the pronoun
When who, which or that is the object of the clause, you can leave it out. There is another subject right after it: the movie (that) we saw. In speech this short form is the usual one.
When the pronoun is the subject, it must stay: the man who lives here, not the man lives here.
Examples
-
The cake you made was delicious.
-
Is this the jacket you were looking for?
-
Everyone I know uses this app.
-
The woman who answered was very kind.
Who is the subject here, so it stays.
Prepositions at the end
When a relative pronoun is the object of a preposition, the preposition usually goes at the end of the clause, and the pronoun is often left out: the house I grew up in, the person I spoke to.
In formal English the preposition can go before which or whom: the house in which I grew up. Never put a preposition before that or who.
Examples
-
That's the girl I told you about.
-
The chair you're sitting on is broken.
-
This is the company for which he works.
Formal style.
No extra pronoun
The relative pronoun replaces the subject or object, so do not repeat it with it, him, her or them. Say the book that I read, not the book that I read it. Many languages repeat the pronoun, so this is a frequent error.
Examples
-
The song that she sang was beautiful.
-
The man who I saw was wearing a hat.
-
Here's the list you asked for.
Common mistakes
-
Wrong The book that I read it was boring.
Right The book that I read was boring.
That already stands for the book. Do not add it in the clause.
-
Wrong The man which called you is my boss.
Right The man who called you is my boss.
For people use who or that, not which.
-
Wrong I have a friend lives in Tokyo.
Right I have a friend who lives in Tokyo.
When the pronoun is the subject of the clause, you cannot leave it out.
-
Wrong This is the city where we visited last year.
Right This is the city that we visited last year.
Visit needs an object, so use that or which, or leave the pronoun out. Where means in that place: the city where we lived.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between which and that?
In defining clauses both refer to things: the car which I bought, the car that I bought. That is more common, especially in American English. In clauses with commas, which add extra information, only which is possible: My car, which is red, is old.
When can I leave out who, which or that?
When the pronoun is the object of the relative clause, so another subject follows it: the man (who) I met, the film (that) we saw. When the pronoun is the subject, it must stay: the man who called. It also cannot be left out in clauses with commas.
Is it correct to end a relative clause with a preposition?
Yes, in everyday English it is normal: the town I grew up in, the people I work with. In formal writing you can move the preposition before which or whom: the people with whom I work. Do not put a preposition before that.
More in this section
Read English at this level
Grammar sticks when you meet it in real sentences. These pages have English texts with a translation under every sentence.