Modal verbs B2

Must have, should have, could have

modal + have + past participle, for deductions and regrets about the past

Quick answer

A modal perfect is a modal + have + past participle: must have left, should have called, could have won. It talks about the past in two ways: guesses about what happened (She must have forgotten) and judgments about what did not happen, such as regrets, criticism and missed chances (I should have listened, We could have won).

Tables

Form and meaning

FormMeaningExample
must have + participlesure it happenedHe must have missed the bus.
might have, may have, could havepossible it happenedShe might have gone home.
might not have, may not havepossible it did not happenThey may not have seen us.
can't have, couldn't havesure it did not happenYou can't have finished already!
should have, ought to havethe right thing that did not happenI should have called you.
shouldn't havea wrong thing that did happenYou shouldn't have said that.
could havea chance that was not takenWe could have taken a taxi.
would havean imagined past resultI would have helped you.
needn't havedone, but it was not necessaryYou needn't have brought a gift.
Have never changes: she must have, not she must has. In speech it is short: must've, should've, could've.

Must have and can't have: sure about the past

Use must have when you are almost sure something happened, based on what you see or know. Use can't have or couldn't have when you are almost sure it did not happen.

As with present deduction, the usual negative of must have is can't have, not mustn't have. American English also uses must not have for a confident negative guess: He must not have heard me.

Examples

  • The ground is wet. It must have rained.

  • She must have forgotten about the meeting.

  • He can't have seen me, he didn't wave.

  • They couldn't have walked here so fast.

Might have, may have, could have: maybe

Use might have, may have or could have when it is possible that something happened, but you don't know. The negatives might not have and may not have mean perhaps it did not happen.

For a guess about an action in progress in the past, use have been + -ing: He might have been sleeping.

Examples

  • I may have left my wallet in the taxi.

  • She might not have heard the phone.

  • The letter could have gotten lost in the mail.

  • He might have been sleeping when you called.

Should have: regret and criticism

Should have + participle says that something was the right thing to do, but it did not happen. Shouldn't have says that something happened but was wrong.

About yourself, it expresses regret: I should have studied. About other people, it criticizes: You should have told me. Ought to have means the same but is less common.

Examples

  • I should have brought an umbrella.

  • You shouldn't have eaten so much cake.

  • We should have booked a table earlier.

  • He ought to have apologized.

Could have: missed chances

Could have + participle says that something was possible in the past, but it did not happen. It can describe a missed chance, a lucky escape, or a mild criticism.

Could have can be about deduction or about a missed chance. The situation shows which: She could have called can mean maybe she called, or she had a chance to call and did not.

Examples

  • We could have won if we had played better.

  • You could have hurt yourself!

  • You could have told me you were coming.

  • I couldn't have done it without your help.

Needn't have or didn't need to

Needn't have + participle means someone did something, but it was not necessary. Didn't need to + base verb usually means it was not necessary, and often that it was not done.

Needn't have is more British. In American English, people usually say didn't have to or didn't need to and add the context.

Examples

  • You needn't have cooked, we already ate.

    You cooked, but it wasn't necessary.

  • We didn't need to take a taxi, so we walked.

  • I needn't have worried, the test was easy.

Pronunciation and the spelling of have

In speech, have after a modal is weak and sounds like of: should've, could've, would've, must've. The written short form is 've.

Never write should of or could of. The word is always have or 've. The negatives are short too: shouldn't have, couldn't have.

Examples

  • You should've seen his face.

  • I could've sworn I locked the door.

  • She must've left early.

Common mistakes

  • Wrong I should of called you.

    Right I should have called you.

    Spoken should've sounds like should of, but the word is have.

  • Wrong He mustn't have seen me.

    Right He can't have seen me.

    For a strong deduction that something did not happen, use can't have or couldn't have. Short mustn't is about rules. American English can say He must not have seen me, uncontracted.

  • Wrong She must have went home.

    Right She must have gone home.

    After have comes the past participle. For irregular verbs it often differs from the past simple.

  • Wrong You should have to tell me.

    Right You should have told me.

    The pattern is modal + have + past participle. Have to is a different verb meaning obligation.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between must have and should have?

Must have is a guess about what happened: He must have left means I'm sure he left. Should have is a judgment about what did not happen: He should have left means leaving was the right thing, but he did not.

Is it should of or should have?

Always should have, or the short form should've. Should of is a spelling mistake that comes from the sound of should've in fast speech. The same is true for could of, would of and must of.

What is the difference between could have and might have?

For a guess about the past they are close: She could have gone and She might have gone both mean maybe she went. Could have also means a past chance that was not taken: You could have asked me. Might have does this mainly in British English, as a complaint: You might have told me. Couldn't have means surely not, while might not have means maybe not.

More in this section

Modal verbs

Read English at this level

Grammar sticks when you meet it in real sentences. These pages have English texts with a translation under every sentence.

Read English books with a translation under every sentence