Must and have to
must and have to for obligation, mustn't vs don't have to
Must and have to both express obligation: I must go, I have to go. Must often shows the speaker's own feeling or a written rule, have to an outside obligation, and only have to has other tense forms: had to, will have to. In the negative they differ: mustn't means it is forbidden, don't have to means it is not necessary.
Tables
Form
| Tense or type | Must | Have to |
|---|---|---|
| present, I / you / we / they | I must go | I have to go |
| present, he / she / it | she must go | she has to go |
| question | Must I go? (rare, formal) | Do I have to go?, Does she have to go? |
| past | no form, use had to | I had to go, Did you have to go? |
| future | must for a future duty | I will have to go |
| present perfect | no form | I have had to go |
| after another modal | no form | You might have to wait |
Negatives: very different meanings
| Form | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| mustn't, must not | it is forbidden, don't do it | You mustn't smoke here. |
| don't have to, doesn't have to | it is not necessary, you can choose | You don't have to pay, it's free. |
| don't need to, doesn't need to | it is not necessary | You don't need to bring anything. |
| needn't | it is not necessary, more British | You needn't wait for me. |
| can't | it is not allowed, everyday | You can't park here. |
Must for your own sense of obligation
Use must when the obligation comes from the speaker: something you feel is necessary or important. It is also common for strong recommendations: You must try this cake.
In everyday American speech, must for obligation sounds formal or strong, and have to or have got to is more usual.
Examples
-
I must call my mother tonight.
-
We must remember to buy milk.
-
You must see that film, it's great.
Must in rules and notices
Written rules, signs, forms and instructions often use must: Passengers must wear seat belts. When people talk about those rules, they usually switch to have to: We have to wear seat belts.
Examples
-
All visitors must sign in at reception.
-
Applications must be received by May 1.
-
Dogs must be kept on a leash.
Have to for outside obligations
Use have to when the obligation comes from outside: a law, a boss, a timetable, the situation. The speaker reports a fact.
Questions and negatives use do and does: Do you have to work tomorrow?, She doesn't have to wear a uniform.
Examples
-
I have to be at work at eight.
-
He has to wear glasses for driving.
-
Do you have to pay for parking here?
-
Students have to show their ID at the door.
Had to, will have to and other tenses
Must has no past or perfect form. For obligation in the past, use had to: I had to work late yesterday. Questions use did: Did you have to wait?
For a future obligation, will have to is the safe choice. Must is possible for a future duty you decide on now: I must call him tomorrow.
Examples
-
We had to walk home because the bus didn't come.
-
Did she have to take the exam again?
-
You will have to book a table.
-
I've had to change my plans twice this week.
Mustn't or don't have to
Mustn't means do not do it, it is forbidden or a bad idea. Don't have to means there is no obligation, you can do it if you want.
Compare: You mustn't tell anyone means keep it secret. You don't have to tell anyone means it is your choice. In American English, mustn't is rare in speech, and people say can't or don't instead: You can't tell anyone.
Examples
-
You mustn't touch that wire, it's dangerous.
-
You don't have to come if you're tired.
-
She doesn't have to work on Sundays.
-
We didn't have to wait long.
Need to, needn't and don't need to
Need to means something is necessary. It works like a normal verb: She needs to rest, Do you need to go? The negative don't need to means the same as don't have to.
Needn't + base verb also means not necessary. It is more British and a little formal; in American English don't need to is the normal form.
Examples
-
I need to get some sleep.
-
You don't need to bring food, we have plenty.
-
You needn't worry about me.
Have got to, informal
Have got to means the same as have to and is common in informal speech, mostly in the present. It is usually short: I've got to go, She's got to work.
In fast American speech it often sounds like gotta. In writing, use have got to or have to.
Examples
-
I've got to finish this by tonight.
-
Have you got to leave so soon?
-
She's got to see a doctor.
Common mistakes
-
Wrong You mustn't pay, the museum is free.
Right You don't have to pay, the museum is free.
Mustn't means it is forbidden. For no obligation, use don't have to.
-
Wrong Yesterday I must stay at home.
Right Yesterday I had to stay at home.
Must has no past form. Use had to for obligation in the past.
-
Wrong She have to work tomorrow.
Right She has to work tomorrow.
Have to is a normal verb, so it takes -s with he, she and it.
-
Wrong Have you to work on Saturday?
Right Do you have to work on Saturday?
Questions with have to use do or does, like other main verbs.
-
Wrong I must to go now.
Right I must go now.
Must is followed by the base verb without to.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between must and have to?
In many sentences both work. Must often shows the speaker's own feeling or a written rule: I must study. Have to reports an obligation from outside: I have to wear a uniform. In the past only had to works, and for the future will have to is the usual choice.
What is the difference between mustn't and don't have to?
They are opposites. You mustn't go means do not go, it is forbidden. You don't have to go means going is not necessary, you can choose. Mixing them up changes the message completely.
Do Americans use must?
Yes, but less for obligation in speech. Americans usually say have to or have got to and keep must for rules and signs, strong advice and deduction, as in You must be tired. Spoken mustn't is rare in the US.
More in this section
Read English at this level
Grammar sticks when you meet it in real sentences. These pages have English texts with a translation under every sentence.