Must, might, can't: modals of deduction
must when sure it is true, might or could for maybe, can't when sure it is not
Modals of deduction show how sure you are that something is true now. Use must when you are almost sure it is true: She must be at home. Use might, may or could when it is possible: He might be busy. Use can't when you are almost sure it is not true: That can't be right.
Tables
Degrees of certainty about now
| Certainty | Modal | Example |
|---|---|---|
| sure it is true | must | The lights are on. They must be home. |
| possible | may, might, could | She might be in a meeting. |
| possible it is not | may not, might not | He may not know about it. |
| sure it is not true | can't, couldn't | It can't be Tom. He's in Paris. |
With be and continuous forms
| Pattern | Example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| modal + be + adjective or noun | You must be tired. | a state now |
| modal + be + place | She could be at the gym. | where someone is now |
| modal + be + -ing | They must be sleeping. | an action in progress now |
| modal + main verb | He might know the answer. | a state verb now |
Must: almost sure it is true
Use must when you have a good reason, often something you can see or know, to believe something is true. You are making a logical conclusion, not stating a known fact.
This must has nothing to do with obligation. You must be hungry means I'm sure you are hungry, not you are required to be hungry.
Examples
-
You've worked all day. You must be tired.
-
She has three cars. She must be rich.
-
That must be the new teacher.
-
He must know her, they work in the same office.
May, might and could: possible
Use may, might or could when something is possibly true but you are not sure. In most sentences the three mean almost the same. Might is very common in speech, may is a bit more formal.
Questions about possibility usually use could or might, or a phrase like Do you think...: Could it be broken?
Examples
-
Ask Sam, he might know the answer.
-
The keys could be in the car.
-
This may be the best restaurant in town.
-
Could she be ill? She didn't come today.
Can't and couldn't: sure it is not true
The usual opposite of must in deduction is can't, not mustn't. Use it when you are sure something is impossible.
American English also uses must not, usually not shortened, for a confident negative guess: Her car is gone. She must not be home. It means you think it is not true, a little less strongly than can't.
Couldn't works the same way and sounds a little softer: It couldn't be him.
Examples
-
That can't be true.
-
She can't be his mother, she's too young.
-
He just ate. He can't be hungry again.
-
It couldn't be my phone, mine is in my bag.
May not and might not versus can't
May not and might not mean it is possible that something is not true. Can't means you are sure it is not true. The difference is your level of certainty.
Couldn't is not the negative of possible could. He couldn't be at home means I'm sure he isn't, while He might not be at home means maybe he isn't.
Examples
-
She might not like spicy food. Let's ask.
-
They may not be home yet.
-
He can't be at home, his car isn't there.
Actions in progress now
To guess about an action happening right now, use the modal + be + -ing. For states, use the modal + main verb or + be + adjective.
Examples
-
He isn't answering. He must be driving.
-
They might be watching the game.
-
She can't be working, the office is closed.
-
Keep your voice down, the baby might be sleeping.
Possibility about the future
May, might and could also talk about future possibility: It might rain later. Might can sound slightly less sure than may, but the difference is small.
Must and can't are not normally used for deduction about the future. For a strong future prediction, use will or will probably.
Examples
-
We might go to the beach this weekend.
-
Take an umbrella, it could rain.
-
I may be late tomorrow.
-
The shop might not be open on Sunday.
Common mistakes
-
Wrong He mustn't be at home, his car is gone.
Right He can't be at home, his car is gone.
In deduction, the usual negative of must is can't. Short mustn't normally means something is forbidden. American English can say He must not be at home, but can't works everywhere.
-
Wrong She must to be at work.
Right She must be at work.
After a modal comes the base verb without to.
-
Wrong May he be at the station?
Right Could he be at the station?
May is not used in questions about possibility. Use could or might, or ask Do you think he's at the station?
-
Wrong Don't call now, she can be asleep.
Right Don't call now, she could be asleep.
For a guess about one situation now, use could, may or might. Can for possibility is used for what is generally possible: It can be cold here in May.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between must and might?
Must shows you are almost sure: She must be at work, because her car is not here. Might shows you think it is possible but you don't know: She might be at work, or she might be at home.
What is the opposite of must in deduction?
Can't. He must be rich means I'm sure he is rich. He can't be rich means I'm sure he is not rich. Mustn't usually means something is forbidden. In American English, must not is also used for a negative guess: He must not be home.
Is there a difference between may, might and could for possibility?
Very little in most sentences. Might is the most common in speech, may is a little more formal, and could often suggests one of several options. The negatives differ: may not and might not mean maybe not, while couldn't means surely not.
More in this section
Read English at this level
Grammar sticks when you meet it in real sentences. These pages have English texts with a translation under every sentence.