Negation and questions A1

Questions: est-ce que and inversion

A rising voice, est-ce que tu viens, or inversion: viens-tu

Quick answer

French has three ways to ask a yes or no question. In speech, keep the normal word order and raise your voice at the end: tu viens ? For a neutral style, put est-ce que in front: est-ce que tu viens ? Inversion, verb then pronoun with a hyphen, is formal: viens-tu ? Between two vowels add -t-: a-t-il, va-t-elle.

Tables

Three ways to ask

WayWhere it is usedExample
Rising voiceeveryday speech, texts to friendsTu parles anglais ?
Est-ce queneutral, speech and writingEst-ce que tu parles anglais ?
Inversionformal speech and writingParles-tu anglais ?

Inversion forms

StatementQuestion with inversion
tu parlesparles-tu ?
vous parlezparlez-vous ?
nous partonspartons-nous ?
il parleparle-t-il ?
elle aa-t-elle ?
on vava-t-on ?
il prendprend-il ?
ils parlentparlent-ils ?
tu as finias-tu fini ?
Paul vientPaul vient-il ?
je peuxpuis-je ?
-t- appears only when the verb ends in a vowel and the pronoun is il, elle or on. A final d or t is already pronounced as t: prend-il, est-il.

A rising voice

The simplest question is a statement said with a rising voice. Nothing else changes, and in writing you add a question mark. This is the most common form in conversation.

It is correct French, not a mistake, but it sounds casual in a formal letter or a job interview.

Examples

  • Tu as faim ?

    Are you hungry?

  • Vous êtes prêts ?

    Are you ready?

  • Il fait froid dehors ?

    Is it cold outside?

  • Ça va ?

    How are you?

Est-ce que: the neutral question

Put est-ce que in front of a normal statement. The word order after it does not change. Before a vowel it becomes est-ce qu': est-ce qu'il pleut ?

Est-ce que has no meaning of its own, it only marks the question. It fits almost any situation, spoken or written.

Examples

  • Est-ce que tu parles anglais ?

    Do you speak English?

  • Est-ce qu'il pleut encore ?

    Is it still raining?

  • Est-ce que vous avez une chambre libre ?

    Do you have a room available?

  • Est-ce que je peux entrer ?

    Can I come in?

Inversion with a pronoun

In formal style, swap the verb and the subject pronoun and join them with a hyphen: vous parlez becomes parlez-vous ? In compound tenses the auxiliary moves: avez-vous fini ?

When the verb ends in a vowel and the pronoun is il, elle or on, add -t- for the sound: a-t-il, parle-t-elle, va-t-on. Inversion with je is rare except in a few set forms: puis-je, ai-je, suis-je.

Examples

  • Parlez-vous français ?

    Do you speak French?

  • A-t-il fini ses devoirs ?

    Has he finished his homework?

  • Va-t-elle venir ce soir ?

    Is she going to come tonight?

  • Puis-je vous aider ?

    May I help you?

Inversion with a noun subject

A noun subject cannot simply move after the verb. It stays in front, and a pronoun that matches it goes after the verb: Paul vient-il ?, ta mère va-t-elle mieux ?

In everyday speech people avoid this and say Paul vient ? or est-ce que Paul vient ?

Examples

  • Le train est-il en retard ?

    Is the train late?

  • Les enfants ont-ils mangé ?

    Have the children eaten?

  • Votre mère va-t-elle mieux ?

    Is your mother feeling better?

  • Cette robe coûte-t-elle cher ?

    Is this dress expensive?

Negative questions

A negative question uses ne ... pas as usual. With inversion, ne goes before the verb and pas after the pronoun: ne viens-tu pas ?, n'avez-vous pas reçu ?

To say yes to a negative question, answer si, not oui.

Examples

  • Tu n'as pas froid ?

    Aren't you cold?

  • Est-ce que tu ne veux pas venir ?

    Don't you want to come?

  • N'avez-vous pas reçu mon message ?

    Didn't you get my message?

Tags: n'est-ce pas, non, hein

To check that the listener agrees, add a short tag at the end, like English isn't it or right. N'est-ce pas is neutral to formal and never changes form. Non is common in speech, and hein is very casual.

Examples

  • Vous venez demain, n'est-ce pas ?

    You're coming tomorrow, aren't you?

  • Il fait beau aujourd'hui, non ?

    It's nice out today, isn't it?

  • C'est joli, hein ?

    It's pretty, huh?

Inversion outside questions

In writing, inversion also appears after a quote: dit-il, répond-elle. After peut-être at the start of a sentence, formal French inverts too: peut-être est-il malade.

In speech, peut-être que with normal word order is much more common: peut-être qu'il est malade.

Examples

  • « Je suis prêt », dit-il.

    I'm ready, he says.

  • Peut-être est-il malade.

    Perhaps he is ill.

  • Peut-être qu'il est malade.

    Maybe he's sick.

Common mistakes

  • Wrong Est-ce que viens-tu ?

    Right Est-ce que tu viens ?

    Use either est-ce que or inversion, never both. After est-ce que the word order stays as in a statement.

  • Wrong A-il fini ?

    Right A-t-il fini ?

    When the verb ends in a vowel, -t- goes between it and il, elle or on.

  • Wrong Vient Paul ?

    Right Paul vient-il ?

    In a yes or no question a noun subject cannot just follow the verb. Keep the noun first and add a pronoun after the verb.

  • Wrong Est-ce que il pleut ?

    Right Est-ce qu'il pleut ?

    Que becomes qu' before a vowel, as everywhere in French.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between est-ce que and inversion in French?

They ask the same question in different registers. Est-ce que tu viens ? is neutral and fits almost anywhere. Viens-tu ? is formal and mostly written. In casual speech the most common form is just tu viens ? with a rising voice.

Why is there a t in a-t-il?

It is there for the sound, to avoid two vowels side by side. It appears when the verb ends in a vowel and the pronoun is il, elle or on: parle-t-il, va-t-on. It means nothing on its own.

Is it correct to ask a question with intonation only?

Yes. Tu as fini ? is standard spoken French and the most frequent question form in conversation. In formal writing, use est-ce que or inversion instead.

More in this section

Negation and questions

Read French at this level

Grammar sticks when you meet it in real sentences. These pages have French texts with a translation under every sentence.

Read French books with a translation under every sentence